|
Joe Schwarcz, the 1999 winner of the American
Chemical Society's James T. Grady-James H. Stack Award for
Interpreting Chemistry for the Public, regularly contributes
to newspapers and other popular media, and a number of
his pieces are collected here. Each of the 67 "digestible"
essays in this book serves as a little dose of antidote against the
evil words--unnatural, toxic, polluting--commonly associated
with chemistry, as well as a reminder that all of life is,
basically, chemistry. The intriguing and attractively written
articles include explanations of how shampoos work, why
chicken soup is good for colds, what can be done with
polyethylene (the source of the book's title), a possible cause for the
Salem witch episode, and many others. More than half the
pieces have to do with either food or health (or both); the rest
cover a wide range of topics, all maintaining close connections
to the familiar.
Dr. Schwarcz's straightforward, not overly
technical language and breezy style are very well suited to the
general audience for whom this book is primarily intended.
Chemists should also find much to interest them, but perhaps
may occasionally feel a little frustrated. A few explanations
are oversimplified to the point of being somewhat
misleading (e.g., the details of how the oxidation of glucose generates
damaging free radicals). There are no chemical structures
at all (or, indeed, any illustrations, except for a handful of
little cartoons), even when the close resemblance between
compounds is central to an argument. A chapter on
homeopathy makes no reference to the Benveniste brouhaha.
Presumably these and other decisions were intended to keep the level
well within the comfort zone of the typical reader. In general
that was probably the right approach, but a few judicious
pushes on the envelope might have been worthwhile.
I was also disappointed in the absence of any
bibliography, particularly with regard to the more controversial
issues addressed, such as the safety of genetically modified
foodstuffs, whether MSG is harmful, or the efficacy of
dietary supplements. In nearly every such case Schwarcz takes a
clear position; he even goes so far as to suggest appropriate
dosages! But the sources of the studies on which he bases
his opinions are given only sketchily--perhaps the name of
a journal, or the location where the work was carried out--or
not at all. It would not have been much trouble to provide a
few references for those interested in following up on any of
these stories, and I assume Schwarcz would hope to stimulate
such initiative, so why not make it easier for the reader?
Aside from these reservations, I quite enjoyed
browsing through the essays, and I expect most general readers
and chemists will too. Every one is entertaining and most are
informative as well, though some, such as the curious
history of Joseph Pujol, "Le Petomane", are not so obviously
relevant to chemistry. But I feel the book could have been
made stronger still; in its present form, the impact of the whole
is a bit less than the sum of its parts.
|