|
The author replies to Crutchfield:
I appreciate Crutchfield's comments, particularly because it is desirable to
ensure to the extent possible that HazMat personnel do not
overreact to any presumed hazards that a substance might possess.
In fact, because of this concern, the CLIP in question specifically
identifies boric acid as a mild oxidizer (1).
(Consequently, I must disagree with Crutchfield's worry that
as a consequence of reading the CLIP on acetic anhydride some
HazMat person might deduce that it is instead a strong oxidizer.)
As to the products of the reduction of boric acid, I have
no specific information; but we all, including Crutchfield,
I presume, know that using heats of formation to predict
that a chemical reaction will or will not occur often leads to
error. The correct procedure is to calculate the change in
free energy that would be associated with the process under the
conditions that exist, which is different from using free
energies of formation, of course. (Enough elementary thermo!)
Hypothesizing, I offer hypoboric acid, BH3OH, or one of the boron
suboxides, perhaps BO, or its dimer or tetramer as possible
products from the reduction of boric acid. There are other
candidates as well, of course. For further detailed information,
carry out the tedious thermodynamic (and kinetic) exercises,
or see the original German literature as cited in Chem.
Eng. News 1973, 51 (34), 42 (2).
Literature Cited
1. Young, J. A. J.
Chem. Educ. 2001,
78, 1176.
2. Chem. Eng. News 1973, 51
(34), 42
|