|
When you get a copy of this Journal every month, what do you look
at first? Do you always go to a specific section, like Chemical Education Today, Chemistry for Everyone, Research, or In the Classroom, or do you go to the table of contents and look for your favorite topic or author? This month’s issue is very interesting. There are many
articles that should appeal to the secondary school educator and you will find them in different sections.
According to Scerri, who wrote this month’s “Commentary”, there is a very
interesting (and argumentative) discussion on what those of us
interested in chemical education research experience. He points out
that “Mainstream chemists understandably view such activities
[chemical education research] as superficial busy-work” (p 468).
I bet many of you can relate to this statement. He points out that
chemical education research pays more attention to theory and less to
discovering new ideas. In his opinion “… chemical education
is currently too simplistic in its underlying ideas” (p 475). He
challenges us to think about our role in the broader aspects of
chemistry. This is really a must-read for any of you who are interested
in entering a graduate program highlighting chemical education
research. If you want to know more about the graduate programs that
exist across the U.S., please check out the DivCHED Committee on Chemical Education Research Web
site and click on the link to the Graduate Programs. Also, in this
commentary Scerri presents many very useful definitions of various
educational learning theories like constructivism, behaviorism, and
relativism.
The next section you might want to peruse is
Chemical Education Today. In this section you will find CLIP (Chemical
Laboratory Information Profile) entries, with different CLIPs appearing
every month. All of these are prepared by Jay Young who does a
marvelous job of keeping us informed about a spectrum of compounds. The
announcements in this section include the
award for high school teachers from across the nation, and upcoming
conferences (like ChemEd 2003 that will be at Auburn University this
summer). Don’t miss the review by Hal Harris of Chemical Misconceptions—Prevention, Diagnosis
and Cure. This two-volume set would be an excellent resource for
any chemical education researcher.
In the Chemistry for Everyone section there are lots of interesting accounts of how
chemistry affects our daily lives. Lykknes and
Kvittingen report on how arsenic has been used both for evil and
medicinal purposes over history. The authors do an excellent report not
only on the historical uses of arsenic, but also describing how its use
has affected the development of some drugs. Those who teach secondary
students might like a game that combines
facts about specific elements and drawing a picture. Bruton presents information regarding an ethics
course that has been well received by both faculty and students at the
University of Southern Mississippi, and Shachter gives us some insights into how her
summer undergraduate research program has incorporated the study of
ethics into the program at Santa Clara University.
In sections
of In the Classroom and In the Laboratory, you can find many ideas to
help you update your classroom and how you teach. These sections
usually present a variety of activities appropriate for many academic
levels. Check out the “Overhead Projector Demonstrations”
by Zingales (one, two), and as usual make sure you look at the JCE Classroom Activity, “Out of the
Blue”. The activity this month gives you some ideas on how to
reimagine the classic Blue Bottle demonstration. On the following
pages, Wellman (who did this demonstration as a high school student)
and her co-authors give us suggestions on how to “green” the Blue Bottle. Some of the
lab activities published in the Journal are for high school use and
some are for the more advanced level. It is usually easy to identify
the difference, but don’t forget to check out the Supplemental Materials that are
online. Some authors (for instance Sowa and
Kondo) will put separate instructions for different levels of
students and give some ideas for guided-inquiry lessons online.
Chemical Education Research manuscripts are published in most
issues. If you are interested in obtaining a graduate degree in
chemical education, look towards the end of each JCE issue.
Not only will you get some ideas on what “ChemEd”
research is currently being done, but you might also get some ideas
on a question you would like to answer—isn’t that what all
research is based on? In this issue you might want to read the research
articles regarding gender differences and regarding a longitudinal study in
college chemistry. This issue has so many interesting
articles that it is hard to mention each one. Where else could you find
such breadth, depth, and strength of chemical education in just one
place? Literature Cited - American
Chemical Society, Division of Chemical Education, Committee on
Chemical Education Research (accessed Mar 2003).
|