| Weekly
Molecules: A Cure for the 8:30 a.m. Blues
The concept of an online molecule of
the time period—day, week, or month,
as in the case of this column—has
increased in popularity since the initial
Web sites created at a number of British
universities in the mid-1990s. The paper
by Sonya Franklin,
Norbert Pienta, and Melissa Fry describes
a study of student responses to a molecule
of the week program. Some of the results
from their surveys of students indicate
that the program indeed helps students
place the chemistry that they are learning
into a broader societal context. Visualizing
these molecules in three dimensions helps
students who have difficulty going from
the two-dimensional drawing to the details
of structure and stereo-chemistry. Some
of the recent controversy that followed
the now infamous comments by Harvard
President Lawrence Summers, brought up,
once again, the debate over whether men
and women have different abilities to
visualize in three dimensions. Many of
us have seen a lot of evidence that such
a difference is not necessarily gender
based, but we should be focusing attention
on ensuring that such differences are
not determining factors for students’ success
in science. At one time students who
could not titrate well were discouraged
from becoming chemists. We should make
certain that we are not discouraging
students for equally unimportant reasons.
Viewing Requirements
In addition to the static image, two fully manipulable versions (Jmol, MDLChime) of these molecules appear below. (The Jmol versions may take a few extr
Download Chime (registration required)
|