|
Composing the Curriculum
For your summer reading pleasure this month's issue provides a wide range
of subjects and activities. Our lead article is a tribute to a
chemist-composer, Lejaren A. Hiller, Jr., as well as an examination of the
interesting relationship between chemistry (and science) and music. Like
Hiller, Wamser and Wamser (page 601) love both chemistry and music, and
this comes through loud and clear in their historical perspective on
Hiller's work.
Much of the rest of the issue impinges on the chemistry curriculum in one
form or another. Rettich, Bailey, Frank, and Frick (page 638) describe an integrated first- and second-year curriculum being developed at Illinois
Wesleyan University that includes all subdisciplines of chemistry. They
describe ways to teach topics such as acids and bases so that the
perspectives of (for example) organic and inorganic chemistry are
integrated and contemporaneous. Those contemplating a popular reform, group
work or cooperative learning, will be interested in Birk and Kurtz's
program (page 615) for training teaching assistants using cooperative
learning. Surely TAs who have participated in cooperative groups to develop
their own techniques for handling discussion and lab sessions will be able
to use group learning to better advantage.
Several years ago the ACS Division of Chemical Education set up a Task
Force on the General Chemistry Curriculum. With support from the National
Science Foundation and others, the task force has been quite active. In
addition to the summative reports published here (pages 617-636) on four
areas in which general chemistry teaching can be improved, they have
contributed many Forum columns in earlier issues of the Journal and have
published much of their work in New Directions for General Chemistry: A
Resource for Curricular Change; Baird W. Lloyd, ed.
Our current approach to teaching electron configurations of the atoms is
largely based on quantum theory Because of the mathematics required,
quantum theory is not accessible to even well prepared introductory
students, except in a qualitative, often confusing, version. Gillespie,
Spencer, and Moog (page 617) provide a new way of introducing the idea of
electron configurations that is based on experimental data instead of
theoretical quantum numbers. Beginning with the periodic table they develop
the inference that electrons must be arranged in shells. They then use
ionization potentials and photoelectron spectra to develop further the
ideas of shell and subshell. This provides a radically different approach
that is at the same time based more firmly on experiment and more
accessible to students.
Gillespie, Spencer, and Moog (page 622) describe an approach to molecular structure that is closely related to the VSEPR theory originally developed
by Gillespie and Nyholm, but does not depend on the orbitals or quantum
mechanics. Their electron domain model is based on electron spin and
electron pairs but not orbitals and provides an interesting way for
students to be introduced to the idea of structure. Birk and Abbassian
(page 636) provide a way of visualizing either orbitals or electron domains
that uses readily available, inexpensive plastic eggs and is a nice
complement to Gillespie, Spencer, and Moog's article.
Spencer, Moog, and Gillespie's third article based on the work of the Task Force on the General Chemistry Curriculum begins on page 627. It develops
the idea of average valence electron energy and applies it to determining
electronegativity values. In the fourth article in this Forum collection,
Spencer, Moog, and Gillespie (page 631) propose that students can much more readily assimilate the ideas of reaction thermodynamics if changes in
enthalpy, entropy, and free energy are all developed in terms of complete
atomization of all reactants followed by putting the atoms back together in
a different way to form products. Their tables of enthalpies, entropies,
and free energies of atomization will be extremely useful to anyone who
wants to adopt this approach.
Maier (page 643) describes a pilot program in polymer science designed to
interest minority students in polymer science and chemistry. This is a
modular program that could be incorporated into a variety of curricula. A
different approach to curriculum and outreach is the combined
biology/chemistry van program described by Craney, Mazzeo, and Lord (page 646). And yet more outreach for younger children is described by Nolan and Gish (page 651).
Information technology can support and aid curriculum reform. The abstract
from JCE: Software is for a CD-ROM that summarizes the work of an
NSF-supported materials science curriculum development project carried out
by Lisensky and Ellis (page 667). The Computer Series includes a proposed addition to the typical physical chemistry curriculum by Williams, Minarik, and Nibler (page 608); it is possible because microcomputers can now do ab initio molecular orbital calculations with reasonable speed.
Demonstrations have long been a part of the curriculum. They are always
popular and usually instructive. Beall (page 641) reports on a conference
that considered the pros and cons of demonstrations as a teaching tool.
Tested Demonstrations includes a means for estimating equilibrium constants
based on the odor of a solution by Anderson, Buckley, and Niewahner (page 639) as well as a way of making ion exchange visible devised by Driscoll
and Villaescuesa (page 640).
A very important and time consuming aspect of curriculum development is
incorporation of new laboratory experiences for students. Mabrouk (page A
149) describes a laboratory that brings biochemistry to the fore. Sundback
(page 669) shows how high school students can test for lead in the
environment, and Rees (page 670) shows how homeowners can easily test for
lead in paint. Elderd, Kildahy, and Berka (page 675) provide a way to use modern GC equipment to show students how to determine whether a fire may
have been arson. In addition to these there are six more new experiments
that you may want to consider incorporating into your curriculum.
A whole summer's worth of reading in one issue! Find something you really
like and use it in your fall classes. Or, better yet, find a dozen things
and use them!
|