|
Saunders College Publishing: New York, 1995. vlvii + 1154 pp.
Figs. and tables. 23.6 x 28.5 cm.
The control by the marketing division of
publishing firms of nearly every aspect of the writing and
production of textbooks for large-enrollment courses leaves
only the slightest opening for originality or individual
flair on the part of authors. One escape hatch is the
preface, which in the present case calls upon Thomas
Jefferson, perhaps uniquely for a text in general biochemistry,
but reasonable (he spoke, we are told, of the "illimitable
freedom of the human mind"), especially by two authors
from the University of Virginia. Both Garrett, trained in
biology, and Grisham, trained in chemistry, are active
and respected practitioners of biochemistry. Their effort
to meld their complementary backgrounds and interests
in an exposition of the elements of biochemistry has
produced a pleasing and generally successful textbook.
The organization follows the current rigidly
enforced scheme, proceeding from molecular principles
(Chapters 1, 2) through biomolecules (small and large,
Chapters 310) and their functions (Chapters 1116, enzymes
and energetics) to metabolism (Chapters 1727) and
molecular genetics (Chapters 2833). All normal matters
under these headings are addressed with literate
intelligence, wit, and the sympathetic understanding of
good teachers.
Fortunately the topics include hemoglobin and
myoglobin as the paradigm of allostery (a section and
an appendix in Chapter 12 on enzyme specificity and
allosteric regulation). Thus the hasty issue of a revised
edition to satisfy those teachers whose notes can know
no change, as occurred with the latest edition of
another text that had the temerity to depart from the good,
gray paradigm, will be unnecessary.
Quite extraordinarily, the text under review
terminates on p. 1100 at the end of Chapter 33
(Molecular Evolution). There are five more chapters (Chapter
34, Self-Assembling Macromolecular Complexes;
Chapter 35, Membrane Transport; Chapter 36, Muscle
Contraction; Chapter 37, The Molecular Basis of Hormone
Action; Chapter 38; Excitable Membranes,
Neurotransmission, and Sensory Systems), apparently about 150 or
so pages in length, marked in the table of contents as
"published separately in a paperback edition entitled
Molecular Aspects of Cell Biology." The purpose of excising a
vital part of the text and publishing it separately is
completely opaque and is nowhere explained.
Presumably as a result, the words "receptor" and
"neurotransmitter" do not appear as entries in the index of the main
text. Not many courses will be taught without requiring
the use of both the text and the so-called "supplement,"
and it is perverse to have divided them.
Besides in the preface of current textbooks,
authorial creativity can also creep into view in the
"enrichment" devices, here represented by "boxes" on
historical points and recent advances and on special-interest
topics (occasionally necessary to follow the text,
however), as well as by references for further reading at the
end of the chapters. The references are well-chosen,
including both classic books and research articles (oddly
few from the 1990s, which may reflect a lengthy
production time for the textbook). In early chapters the
references are given without comment, but later in the book,
annotation becomes more common. The "boxes" are
always good, sometimes fascinating, occasionally arguable
(is "stumbles onto" the right verb for Pauling's discovery
of the a-helix?) and rarely, a little odd (the similarity
between the imidazole of histidine and the five-ring of
purines as a suggestion of the RNA world).
Overall, Garrett and Grisham's
Biochemistry is a very well-designed, well-written, attractive and
useful textbook. The gambit of chopping off the last bit of
the book and publishing it separately is strange and
unfortunate.
|