|
It was almost the biggest ACS Meeting ever, and
for the Division of Chemical Education, there were more
programs, more student research posters, and more
papers than before. Here are a few highlights.
There was a mesh of old and new, as demonstrated
by Joe Lagowski, who presented the paper "Using the
Internet To Help Students Learn General Chemistry" and then
attended "Press On Regardless", the symposium held to
honor him for his 17 years as editor of the Journal of
Chemical Education. For many of us the Division's banquet cruise
was something specialexcellent weather, magnificent views
of the Bay bridges, and the sight of Hale-Bopp Comet over
San Francisco Bay.
A theme that stood out at this meeting was the
large number of symposia dealing with the
process of chemical education rather than the
content within chemical education courses. Even in symposia that concentrated on
the World Wide Web and multimedia, the questions of
student retention and assessment of a project relative to
learning were continually addressed. You can expect symposia on
the general topic of course and program assessment at
future meetings, too.
Chemistry Teaching and the WWW

Ludy Mayer in the basement switch room of the Crowne Plaza Parc Hotel helping install and test phone lines for the WWW symposium
Papers presented here show that developments are
occurring so rapidly and the wealth of information on the
Web is so vast that the issue is not creation of new
materials but rather integration of existing materials into student
activities. However, the amount of work necessary to
mount this symposium is a warning to those who want to go
on-line in the classroom. Many of the papers were given
using simulated rather than real hot-links. Mary Freilich of
the University of Memphis had an interesting system for
her presentation, where the hot-link button and a
simulated button for the downloaded material were side-by-side.
The choice could be made of which way to go. Koni Stone of
California State University at Stanislaus presented
interesting projects in biochemistry and instrumental analysis,
in which students produced a website review journal. The
lure of instant publication of their papers was quite an
incentive for better writing. For those teaching physical or
analytical chemistry, the websites of Theresa Zielinski
of Niagara University and Brian Tissue of Virginia Tech
are valuable resources. However, Jimmy Reeves of North Carolina,
Wilmington, commented that the full power of WWW
technology is at least one large step awayuntil Java
is fully established, more complex interactive
learning on the WWW cannot easily take place. (The URL sites for all
these talks are listed in the abstracts that appear in
the Division's Spring 1997 CHED Newsletter.)
The Student Program
For the almost 2,000 undergraduate students at
the meeting, this was an exciting and fulfilling activity.
Jiwon Kim, the new Student Affiliates person at ACS, was
really busy with details and needless to say, the attendance at
the student research posters was excellent. Some of the
old hands involved with the Student Affiliates program
commented that these posters are getting so good that they
rival those in the traditional poster sessions. Some of this
is due to the fact that the Student Affiliates Office now
divides papers into categories so that professionals in an area
can easily go to the posters of their choice to evaluate the
student work.
The Graduate Student Fair is another of the
activities within the Student Program that are watched by
chemistry faculty at many research institutions. Many of the
attendees at the Fair are sophomores and juniors looking
for a direction in chemistry, and their Student Affiliate
advisors have suggested that going to the meeting and attending the Fair is a good way to resolve some graduate
school questions. At this meeting the Fair was held
simultaneously with the research posters, and this proximity helped
immensely in attracting students to the Fair booths. Upon
interviewing faculty participants at the conclusion of the
Fair, these rough generalizations can be made:
- For established research institutions, recruitment
of students at the Fair may not meet with great
success. Perhaps this is because students already of
know about established programs and are looking for
alternatives.
- For smaller or specialized programs, success at
attracting students appears to be better. These
programs are gathering name recognition that is
- The Fair is much like a college fair for high school
students. Don't send your introverted research star
to this operation.
- Students are looking for particular programs.
The buzz words are very definitely biochemistry,
environmental chemistry, and materials science.
One-Liners

William Kieffer, former editor of the Journal and Joseph Bunnett, former editor of Accounts of Chemical Research enjoying a moment together at the banquet cruise.
Judging from the level of interest, guided
design in the laboratory, course, and curriculum is a very
attractive idea. Attendance at the session New
Traditions: A Guided Inquiry Approach to General Chemistry
Curriculum overflowed into the hallway so that even though
I chair the Division's program committee I was not able to
elbow my way into the meeting room! However, I heard reports
that James Spencer's approach to the complete guided design
general chemistry course being used at Franklin and Marshall
College was strongly received.
The awards symposium was instructive, inspiring, and, in the case of
Robert Becker's presentation, explosive. The two Dreyfus
Award winners, Mary Thompson, for Encouraging Women into
Careers in the Chemical Sciences, and Billy Joe Evans, for
Encouraging Disadvantaged Students into Careers in
the Chemical Sciences, were not very complimentary about
institutional activities now being conducted to help in
these activities. In particular, Evans assessed many of
the mentoring programs now in place as "just advising in
disguise". To paraphrase him: Your impact is most
effective when you get into the boat with the student and start
off together on this tumultuous journey.
|