|
William C.
Brown: Dubuque, IA, 1997. xxii + 1104 pp. Figs. and tables.
20.9 X 26.0 cm. ISBN: 0 8151 8450 6. $83.00.
Olmsted and Williams's Chemistry: The Molecular
Science, now in its second edition, remains unique among
general chemistry texts in the extent to which it emphasizes an
atomic and molecular point of view. In the preface, the authors
exhort the student to
Think molecules. Every phenomenon in chemistry
has an atomic/molecular basis that can make the
phenomenon easier to understand. Ask yourself what the
molecules are doing and why.
And throughout the book the material is consistently
presented in ways designed to help students develop this perspective.
The most obvious implementation of the authors'
molecular focus is the incorporation of numerous
"molecular pictures", which help to emphasize a particulate
description of matter. This type of illustration has drawn
considerable attention recently in this
Journal and elsewhere as a way of enhancing conceptual understanding. Although several
textbooks have now begun to include such diagrams in
some chapters, here they are practically ubiquitous. Open to
any chapter and you will find phenomena illustrated at the
molecular scale: reaction mixtures demonstrating
stoichiometry, solutions showing the presence of dissociated ions or
intact molecules, liquid/vapor equilibria showing the physical
differences between the two phases, geometrical structures
of both simple and more complex molecules. Beyond
these illustrations, the authors have also shaped the text itself
to focus on the molecular viewpoint. In presenting kinetics,
for example, they start by describing a simple reaction
mechanism in molecular terms and then develop rate laws as a
macroscopic ramification of the molecular behavior. Similarly,
the problem-solving strategy employed throughout the
text teaches the student to "think molecules" before thinking
about equations, which should help foster conceptual
rather than algorithmic understanding.
In the second edition, the authors have made a
number of changes designed to improve the pedagogy of the text.
To increase student interest, each chapter now begins with a
brief exploration of a practical or contemporary application of
the ideas to be developed. Chapter 8, Fundamentals of
Chemical Bonding, opens with a discussion of molecular modeling,
and the introduction to Chapter 11, Macromolecules,
discusses the use of polymers in prosthetics. End-of-chapter
problems are now presented in a paired format, in which each
odd-numbered problem is followed by a similar
even-numbered problem. (Odd-numbered problems appear in the
student solution manual.) The student's and instructor's
solution manuals were rewritten by one of the text authors and
are now completely consistent with the approach used in the text.
As might be expected in a second edition, there are
also some changes in content and presentation. The
systematic procedure used for constructing Lewis structures has
been modified, reducing its reliance on formal charges
somewhat. The discussion of molecular orbitals has been
simplified slightly, although it is still more extensive than that found
in most texts. Several definitions and derivations in the
chapters on thermodynamics have been clarified. What was
Chapter 18, The Chemistry of Lewis Acids and Bases, in the
first edition has been expanded into two chapters in the
new edition: Chapter 18, The Transition Elements, and Chapter
19, The Main Group Elements. This change incorporates
more descriptive chemistry than was present in the first
edition. Finally, it appears that a number of minor errors present
in the first edition have been corrected.
The second edition of Chemistry: The Molecular
Science retains all the strengths of the book, including the
molecular focus, the integration of organic molecules into
examples throughout the text, and a large number of problems
framed in the context of industrial, environmental, biological,
or pharmaceutical applications. Revisions have been made which
should improve the clarity of presentation for several
topics. The book merits serious consideration by general
chemistry instructors who are looking for a more conceptual focus
than that found in many texts.
Larry Brown
Department of Chemistry
Texas A&M University
College Station, TX 77843
|