|
Plenum: New York, 1997. xx + 260
pp. Figs., tables, photos. 15 x 22.8 cm. ISBN
0-306-45558-7. $27.50.
Science education is undergoing an
upheaval more fundamental than the one that occurred in the aftermath of
Sputnik. Research during the past 40 years has led to a radical
change in the way we view children's learning of science. The
National Science Education Standards (NSES) suggest a new model
for teaching science based upon these research findings.
Societal changes, particularly changes in business, have put
pressure on schools to alter the emphasis of curricula from
rote memory and individual competition to problem solving
using a variety of technological skills and teamwork/team
competition. This timely book addresses all these issues by
describing projects that K-12 teachers can use to achieve the goals
set forth by both NSES and business. It also provides
scientists with examples of how they and their coworkers might
better interact with K-12 science education to encourage a
more scientifically literate society. Finally, it includes
suggestions for future research in science education.
This book provides descriptions of a number of
programs that encourage students in grades K-12 (and interested
others) to interact with scientists in a manner that enhances
students' understanding of the process of inquiry through
Student-Scientist Partnerships (SSPs). The projects include the
GLOBE program, Feeder Watch, Sun Photometer
Atmospheric Network (SPAN), the Aquanaut Program, Earth Watch,
Mars Exploration, and Image Processing. For each of these
programs, examples of how teachers have used these opportunities
to expand their students' and their own understanding of
open-ended inquiry are described. The appendix includes a list
of contact persons for each of these programs, as well as
many others including the Desert and Desertification
Project; GREEN; Journey North; the Natural Resources,
Science, Mathematics, and Engineering Program; the Student
Research Apprenticeship Program; and many others. Some of the
critical aspects of all these projects are that students are engaged
in authentic problem solving, that is, true inquiry (not
simply completing labs with preset answers); they use
technology appropriately (these research projects could not be done
more efficiently in any other way); they use technology as an
integral part of learning scientific concepts (not just glorified
workbook pages or fancy thermometers); and they interact
with others interested in the same problems, including
scientists and other groups of peers.
The descriptions of the projects do not neglect
other important issues such as accuracy of data collection and
data verification, types of needed hardware and software, and
the critical nature of technical support. Data accuracy is not
only important for students, but is also critical to the usefulness
of the data to scientists and the broader research
community. The types of data verification in SSPs vary from peer
monitoring (Project North), to scientist monitoring with
subsequent discarding of implausible data (Feeder Watch), to
statistical analysis of data using an Error Matrix (GLOBE).
Mims, Kreuger et al., Morse and Sabelli, and Pea (Chapters 4, 9,
10, and 11, respectively) provide excellent descriptions of
types of hardware and software needed for conducting research
using SSPs. The project of Pea et. al. is one of the more
ambitious with respect to the kinds of computer hardware and
software necessary. The Mims project uses less sophisticated
computer applications but still attends to the basic
requirements for successful research involving SSPs. The
underpinning philosophy of the book, however, is that technology should not be
used for technology's sake. Rather, it should be used as
necessary for productive inquiry. This idea was recently
highlighted both by the educational technology community at the
Ernest L. Boyer Technology Summits (which included
representatives from all 50 states and Puerto Rico) and by
NCATE (National Council for the Accreditation of Teacher
Education) in their the recent recommendations for changes in
certification guidelines.
The projects also include a broad definition of
scientist-not only university research scientists, but also such
diverse individuals as architects, engineers, forest
conservationists, amateur scientists, undergraduate and graduate
students, precollege students, and science teachers. This broader
definition provides for a greater variety of potential and
relevant partnerships appropriate to almost any science
teaching-learning environment such as K-12 schools,
alternative schools, and museums.
Through the project descriptions, the book also
provides teacher educators with examples of how technology is being
used in elementary, middle, and high schools to enhance
students' understanding of science concepts. This is especially
critical given upcoming changes in NCATE accreditation
standards requiring preservice teachers to have experience
integrating technology with conceptual learning.
Finally, the example programs described suggest to
the science community means by which they might engage
in broad-scale research previously not feasible. The pressure
to publish, to complete a report to superiors or the voting
public, or to produce a sellable product often limits projects to
those that can produce results in a short period of time.
Limited funding further inhibits the breadth of studies by limiting
the number of data collection sites. By enlisting the assistance
of public school students and the general public, scientists
can engage in projects as broad as migration patterns of
various animal species (e.g., Feeder Watch and Project North),
interactions between weather patterns and the biosphere (e.g., the
GLOBE Project) and even determine factors that affect
marine environments (e.g. the Aquanaut Program). Scientists can
also better utilize data being sent back from space (e.g.,
Mars Exploration).
This is an excellent resource for preservice and
inservice teachers interested in finding out about opportunities
for themselves and their students to engage in true inquiry,
for scientists interested in becoming more involved with
K-12 science education, and for teacher educators wanting a
concise reference for current SSP programs.
|