|
Oxford University Press: Oxford, 1998. xiii
+ 250 pp (incl. index). Hardback, ISBN
0-19-850266-4. $25.00. Paperback, ISBN 0-19-850379-2.
Chemistry books for nonscientists are not as abundant
as their counterparts in physics, planetary sciences, or
biology. John Emsley's book Molecules at an
Exhibition helps to correct that discrepancy.
Many Journal readers will know of Emsley's work
through his earlier prize-winning book The Consumer's
Chemical Guide: A Jargon-Free Guide to the Chemicals of Everyday
Life (W. H. Freeman, 1994) and his regular Chemistry in
Britain column. In Molecules At An
Exhibition, Emsley again gives readers, lay and professional alike, an intriguing tour of some
chemical landscapes. The book is developed from articles written for
a regular "Molecules of the Month" column in
The Independent newspaper and from pieces that appeared in the
author's "Radicals" feature column in
Chemistry in Britain. The idea of an exhibition of molecules developed from Emsley's
friendship with Alfred Bader, noted chemist and art collector.
The book's title derives from that of
Moussorgsky's famous piano suite Pictures at an
Exhibition, based on drawings by Victor Hartmann, his contemporary and friend. The work
was later transcribed for orchestra by Maurice Ravel.
In contrast, Emsley's creation needs no transcription.
He organizes the work around a vicarious "trip"
through a molecular museum of eight galleries (chapters), each
exhibiting eight to 13 fascinating portraits of elements and
compounds having important technological and societal applications
and implications. The gallery tour includes
Gallery 1: Nearly as Nature Intended- An exhibition
of some curious molecules in the foods we eat;
Gallery 2: Testing Your Metal- An exhibition of
the metals which our body must have;
Gallery 3: Starting Lives, Saving Lives, Screwing
Up Lives- An exhibition of molecules that can help
and harm the young;
Gallery 4: Home, Sweet Home- An exhibition of
detergents, dangers, delights, and delusions;
Gallery 5: Material Progress and Immaterial
Observations- An exhibition of molecules that make life a little easier;
Gallery 6: Landscape Room: Environmental
Cons, Concerns, and Comments- An exhibition of
molecules that stalk the world;
Gallery 7: We're on the Road to Nowhere- An
exhibition of molecules to transport us; and
Gallery 8: Elements from Hell- An exhibition of
molecules that are mainly malevolent.
There is also a quick guide to things large and small
offering useful comparisons for various weights and measures,
such as "A gram is about the weight of a peanut."
The writing style is straightforward and engaging, with
the occasional witticism so characteristic of Emsley; for
example, "Drinking rhino horn tea [for its purported
aphrodisiacal effects], the traditional way of taking it, will have the
same effect as making tea from your own nail clippings."
There are several English terms unfamiliar to many United
States citizens-sweets (candy), nappies (diapers), crisps (chips),
lorries (trucks-)but they are used in sufficient context and
are not in great enough numbers to be problematic.
Throughout the book are delightful accounts and anecdotes
about consumer products. For example, Emsley relates the
buildup and then decrease of lead in French wines to the
introduction and subsequent elimination of tetraethyl lead in gasoline.
He provides a splendidly detailed account of the workings of
an auto air bag. Drawing on W. S. Gilbert's poem
Ozone, Emsley points out the erroneous sense of the time that ozone
was abundant at higher altitudes and deficient in cities,
the opposite of what we know today.
There also are accounts of Brazilian bees that
actually seek out and store DDT, possibly for use as a sex
attractant; of distances measured in terms of cups of tea necessary for
the journey; and of scientific rivalries such as that of Heatley
and Moyer over penicillin. These are but a few of the
fascinating accounts featuring chemistry's pervasive impact on our lives.
The book is not, however, error free. There are a
number of annoying misspellings (attached vs attacked, particlers
vs particles, CDM vs DCM), which should have been picked
up by a spell checker or in proof reading. I would have
preferred that the term iron ions rather than metal be used in
conjunction with iron in the body. More serious are the
factual errors. The atomic weight of beryllium is given as 10, which
is actually the mass number of Be-10, not the atomic
weight of beryllium. Plants are claimed to have produced almost
all the nitrogen for biomass until chemists were able to
fix nitrogen. This overlooks the fact that plants do not fix
nitrogen at all, but use the atmospheric nitrogen fixed by bacteria
and lightning as a water-soluble nitrogen source that they
incorporate into organic nitrogen compounds. Cadmium
chloride is described as insoluble, yet its solubility (140 g/100 g water)
is more than three times that of sodium chloride (<40 g/100
g water). The statement "Until the human population
decreases we have no option but to tap the vast reserves of nuclear
and fossil fuels with which the planet is endowed" fails to
take into account the role fuel conservation measures could play.
And the comment regarding a daily dietary intake of manganese
of 1-10 mg "the upper value of which is not far off the
dangerous intake of 20 mg" undermines the 200% safety
factor.
The most serious drawback to the book is its
complete lack of any "pictures" (line drawings, photos, or
structural formulas). It is ironic that a book about exhibiting
molecules should fail to use structural formulas, a primary
method to display such molecules. Drawings of simple
structural formulas and illustrations would have been most helpful
in the "exhibition" of ethylene and polyethylene,
polystyrene, the explanation of isotactic and syndiotactic
polypropylene, and the malevolent molecules sarin and tear gas.
Noting the presence of functional groups would have
helped the explanations of polymerization.
These drawbacks aside, the book is a delightful
romp through wonderfully selected exemplars of the chemical
world around us. Chemists, particularly professors, will find
it useful for its notable (and quotable) tales of the
discovery, applications, and "personalities" of the selected
molecules. The nonscientist will gain a better entrée into the broad
sweep of chemicals that sustain and challenge us.
Molecules at an Exhibition makes a significant contribution to
demystifying chemistry. It belongs on our bookshelves.
|