|
D. M. Hawcroft. Oxford University Press: Oxford,
1997. 142 + xii pp. Index. ISBN 0-19-963563-3. $100.00.
This concise monograph is one of a series on
techniques in widespread use in biochemistry and cell and
molecular biology. It seeks to present, in compact and readable
form, the fundamentals of electrophoresis and does so very
well. Both theory and practice are included, but emphasis is
on the latter. Although the preface makes it clear that this
book is intended for biologists, it also deserves a
place in a truly complete chemistry library.
The book is logically organized. Each of the nine
chapters corresponds to either a step in an electrophoresis
experiment (e.g., Chapter 7: Visualization of Separated Materials) or
a major application (Chapter 4: The Electrophoresis of
Native and Denatured Proteins). It is written as though the
reader is getting ready to begin doing electrophoresis for
the first time and needs a survey of the technique and its applications.
A question that occurred to me repeatedly as I
read through the book is: Exactly how did the author intend it
to be used? One can view the book as either a text or a
laboratory manual. As a resource that might be used as a
supplementary text in a graduate or upper-division undergraduate course,
it does an admirable job of presenting a thorough overview
of modern electrophoresis. The figures and diagrams are
exceptionally clear and present useful comparisons of
results that can be obtained under a variety of conditions (e.g., the
resolution of DNA fragments obtained with otherwise
identical wedge and normal gels). Not all its explanations,
however, are as cogent. It defines how the two portions of a
discontinuous gel differ but fails to explain clearly how the
porosity and pH differences result in the stacking effect, which is
such a gel's primary advantage.
Having it on hand as a laboratory manual would
be much like having colleagues who are experts in all phases
of electrophoresis to consult or to go to with problems.
The author uses bullets and numerous well-organized
tables throughout the text and its appendices to summarize
important information.
One weakness in the book as a lab manual is a
paucity of references. For example, colloidal gold
is suggested as a quick way of enhancing the sensitivity of the
widely used silver stains for proteins, but no
reference to experimental details is provided. Another weakness in this area is a lack
of examples of how electrophoretic data are interpreted
and used. While sample papers or lists of references would
have made the book longer and more formidable, they would
have been invaluable to a true novice in this field.
The book gives short shrift to laboratory safety.
Safety information is compiled into one chapter with the
admonition to "read this before starting practical work", but the fact
that it is the book's last chapter makes it a bit unlikely that
many will. The chapter discusses the hazards of acrylamide in
some detail but dismisses the similarly severe hazards of
ethidium bromide in a single sentence. There is no
mention of the dangers of the latter compound in the chapter where its
value as a stain is extolled.
Electrophoresis: The
Basics compiles a large amount of useful information in a single source. It provides a
comprehensive view of the available techniques and their
many variations. A researcher who wishes to employ some of
the more unusual ones will, however, have to dig a bit
deeper.
|