|
Nicholas A. Ashford and Claudia S. Miller. Van
Nostrand Reinhold: New York, 1998. 440 pp. ISBN
0-442-02524-6. $39.95.
My first reaction as I began reading this book is that
the subject does not match the expectation I had formed
from the title. I expected Chemical
Exposures to cover examples of classical and newly discovered chemical toxicities from
environmental, industrial, and other settings over the full
range of concentrations. The subtitle, Low Levels and High
Stakes, does indicate that the focus is on the lower limits of
sensitivity. In fact, this book focuses on a relatively narrow,
controversial area of so-called "chemical sensitivity" or "multiple
chemical sensitivity" (MCS). I don't emphasize this point to be
critical of the book, because the authors take a rational,
scientific approach to this important subject; but I do want to
alert potential readers to the fact that a more narrow subject
is covered than they might assume from the title.
Unlike many second editions, this book is not a
rewrite of information in the earlier edition but rather focuses
on MCS literature published since 1991. It is presented in
four parts: Part I is Defining Chemical Sensitivity; Part II
is Mechanisms, Diagnosis and Treatment; Part III is
Responding to the Problem; and Part IV is Update since the
First Edition.
In Part I, Ashford and Miller define and describe
MCS and related terms and concepts. Their definition of
the condition is based on a process of environmental testing
of patients, first, by removal of the suspected offending
agent, and second, after an appropriate period of time,
by rechallenge. A number of occupational and
environmental scenarios are described that have been associated with
MCS, and a listing of offending substances is provided.
Part II presents several possible physiologic or psychogenic
mechanisms for the development of MCS. There are also discussions
of methods for diagnosis and treatment of MCS and the
controversies surrounding the condition between allergists
and clinical ecologists. Ashford and Miller provide a
description in Part III of how MCS is viewed by society,
governmental agencies, and the law. They describe their concerns and
offer recommendations on directions for research, the health
care system, and governmental policy. Part IV provides a
review of research and other developments on MCS since the
first edition was published in 1991. This is the most
comprehensive part of the book, with a section on changes in
governmental policies and actions relative to MCS and a summary of
recent research findings. This includes discussion of some "hot"
topics such as the reported increases in chemical sensitivity in
veterans of the Gulf War and in women with silicone breast
implants.
There are also informative appendices on Health
Effects Associated with Chemicals or Foods, Laboratory
Diagnostic Tests Used in MCS Studies, and an Environmental
Exposure and Sensitivity Inventory. An extensive bibliography
is provided with references through 1996.
This is a valuable book for anyone who has an
ongoing interest in MCS or for those new to the field who
would like to be brought up to date on the subject. The
authors have done a good job providing a comprehensive
overview of both research and societal issues and the
health-related controversy associated with low-level chemical exposure.
|