|
Recently, I reviewed Maitland Jones's
Organic Chemistry for this Journal
(J. Chem. Educ. 1998, 75, 291). In
that review, I commented that "[a] useful addition would be
the inclusion of a CD-ROM containing animations of the
orbital interactions." I am pleased to report that Jones
now comes with a copy of the Organic Reaction
Animations CD by Fleming, Savage, and Hart, which contains
animations of organic reactions discussed in the text.
The CD is an excellent accompaniment to
Organic Chemistry. The fifty animations are accessed through a
table of contents that is cross-referenced to page numbers in
the text, making it easy to find the reaction of interest
quickly. The animations themselves are clear and can be viewed in
a ball-and-stick, space-filling, HOMO, or LUMO mode. It
is even possible to switch between viewing modes in the midst
of an animation. The animations can be put on a
slow-motion setting to permit better visualization and are
accompanied by an energy diagram, making it easy to identify
transition states and intermediates. Electron flow is apparent in
the HOMO and LUMO modes, allowing the student to
link curved arrows and orbital interactions.
The window is clean and uncluttered, presenting the
user with a very intuitive interface. All controls are clearly
marked, and the animations are large enough to see easily. A
separate window describing the reaction is accessed by a button
at the bottom of the window. The animations are
Quicktime movies of calculations performed with Wavefunction's
Spartan program, and a Quicktime installer is included for those
who do not have this piece of software.
Of course, I must grouse a little bit. Having seen
this very impressive CD, I'm ready for the next generation of
animations--wouldn't a fully interactive 3-D approach,
which would allow the user to rotate the molecules, be even
better? I found myself trying to peer around the back of
molecules to see what they looked like from another angle!
This is a Mac/Win dual-platform CD. It installed
and ran flawlessly on both a PowerMac 4400/200 running
Mac OS 8.6 and a Micron Millennia MXE running Windows
95, although the images appeared to be sharper on the Mac.
The animations are large enough that they can easily be seen
upon projection, even from the last row of a 112-student
lecture hall.
Fleming, Savage, and Hart have assembled an
excellent accompaniment to Jones's Organic
Chemistry. It is a major upgrade to an already impressive organic textbook.
|