|
Prentice Hall; Upper Saddle River, NJ, 2001. vi + 91 pp. ISBN 0-13-029284-2. Paperback, $18.00.
This pleasing little book is intelligently designed to
be useful to a busy teacher. The authors make a convincing
case for the importance of writing activities in all
chemistry courses, not only for the development of writing skills
useful in a professional career, but also as a way of enhancing
the learning of chemistry by requiring students to actively
process ideas and information. The authors quickly get down to
the practical matters of designing effective writing
assignments, grading the results, and responding to students in ways
that encourage their continuing development. While I have
often made use of writing assignments in some of my classes,
I came to this book with no formal background in
writing instruction and little familiarity with the extensive
literature on this subject. Nevertheless, I found that the authors
were writing at just the right level for me.
They point out that designing effective
assignments requires awareness of basic rhetorical forms (an
eightfold hierarchy ranging from listing, through summary, and up
to scientific argument). The book also suggests appropriate
levels of difficulty within each form and discusses both
informal and formal writing tasks. This presentation is particularly
easy to follow because many examples of actual assignments
are provided along the way. (An example of an assignment
on the classification mode: "Essentially all simple
inorganic reactions can be classified as either precipitation,
acid-base, or oxidation-reduction reactions. Provide a clear
definition and examples for each category. Identify the basis for
classification of each example.")
Chapter 3 deals with general strategies for using
writing in a chemistry course or in a sequence of courses, and it
sets the stage for the detailed discussions in following chapters.
Chapter 4 focuses on grading writing either holistically
or analytically, and offers practical advice on timesaving
ways to do this without loss of objectivity. Examples of
grading charts are included. I was impressed by the description of
ways to train graders. The matter of how best to provide
feedback to students is addressed in Chapter 5. Here again the
discussion is helped along by inclusion of actual examples of
student paragraphs, with possible teacher's markings and marginal comments.
Chapter 6 is made up mostly of sample
assignments, broken down into categories, that can be used in
various chemistry courses. Some of the sample topics in the
Content-Specific category are Acids and Bases, Atomic
Theory, Thermodynamics, and Chemical Bonding. Other
categories include Reintegration/Enrichment (analyzing
chemistry content in relation to other disciplines),
Exam-Preparation, and Professional Advancement (e.g., resumé preparation).
This chapter is impressive testimony to the many ways that
writing assignments can be used to achieve different learning goals.
The final chapter is an extensive annotated
bibliography of style guides, usage guides, Internet resources, and
papers dealing with science writing. Those interested in
including writing as an activity in their courses are likely to get
some good ideas from this book. If you do not include writing
in your courses, this book is likely to convince you that
you should. Indeed, chemistry department faculty would
benefit from collectively reading and discussing this book. It
makes a strong case for integrating writing activities in a
sensibly sequenced manner throughout the entire four-year
college chemistry experience.
|